Azure Prompt Shield vs Meta Prompt Guard 2 86M

Detailed comparison for runtime guardrails

AzureMeta

On Guardion's Prompt Attack Risk Benchmark, Meta Prompt Guard 2 86M is the more secure of the two: Prompt Shield scores NaN% and Prompt Guard 2 86M scores NaN% on F1 score (higher is better).

Head-to-Head Overview

Prompt Shield is the overall winner in this comparison!

Guardrail Metrics

F1 Score

Prompt Shield
42.980
Prompt Guard 2 86M
0.000

Accuracy

Prompt Shield
59.410
Prompt Guard 2 86M
0.000

Precision

Prompt Shield
93.520
Prompt Guard 2 86M
0.000

Recall

Prompt Shield
27.900
Prompt Guard 2 86M
0.000

False Positive Rate

Prompt Shield
2.350
Prompt Guard 2 86M
0.000

False Negative Rate

Prompt Shield
72.100
Prompt Guard 2 86M
0.000

Average Latency (ms)

Prompt Shield
0.173
Prompt Guard 2 86M
0.000

p50 Latency (ms)

Prompt Shield
169.357
Prompt Guard 2 86M
0.000

p90 Latency (ms)

Prompt Shield
203.948
Prompt Guard 2 86M
0.000

Key Highlights

  • Azure Prompt Shield has a better F1 Score.
  • Azure Prompt Shield has a better Accuracy.
  • Azure Prompt Shield has a better Precision.
  • Azure Prompt Shield has a better Recall.
  • Meta Prompt Guard 2 86M has a better False Positive Rate.
  • Meta Prompt Guard 2 86M has a better False Negative Rate.
  • Meta Prompt Guard 2 86M has a better Average Latency (ms).
  • Meta Prompt Guard 2 86M has a better p50 Latency (ms).
  • Meta Prompt Guard 2 86M has a better p90 Latency (ms).

Security Profile

Outward is better on every axis.

F1 ScoreAccuracyPrecisionRecallFPRFNRAverage Latency (ms)p50 Latency (ms)p90 Latency (ms)
Prompt Shield
Prompt Guard 2 86M
Full security profile
Azure Prompt Shield
Full security profile
Meta Prompt Guard 2 86M

Frequently asked questions

Is Azure Prompt Shield or Meta Prompt Guard 2 86M more secure?

On Guardion's Prompt Attack Risk Benchmark, Meta Prompt Guard 2 86M is the more secure of the two: Prompt Shield scores NaN% and Prompt Guard 2 86M scores NaN% on F1 score (higher is better).

What is the F1 score of Prompt Shield vs Prompt Guard 2 86M?

Prompt Shield scores NaN% F1 and Prompt Guard 2 86M scores NaN% F1 on Guardion's prompt-attack benchmark. F1 balances precision and recall — higher is better.

How were Prompt Shield and Prompt Guard 2 86M tested?

Both were evaluated via API at production-like sensitivity against 30+ prompt-attack categories using zero-shot, Crescendo, and TAP methods, scored by F1.

Related Comparisons